Comments for Preserve Rock Canyon

Comment on Forest Service Concern for Rock Canyon by Ryan McBride

Ryan McBride — Mon, 12 Oct 2009 01:04:17 +0000

I appreciate the Forest Service’s efforts, and hope they know that I personally appreciate them — and hope they will continue to try to make headway to preserve Rock Canyon. I believe this is the hour where the nobility of our leaders and government agencies will be tested — Now they have the opportunity to make choices and policies that will affect our quality of life and that of future generations. I love Rock Canyon and hope my children can enjoy it too.

Mr. Ferebee, thanks for your continuing efforts.

Comment on Steve Clark for Provo City Mayor by garold n davis

garold n davis — Thu, 10 Sep 2009 17:47:50 +0000

I have known Steve Clark for many years and have known him to be an advocate for protecting our natural environment, which I like. He has been an avid horseman and has traversed many of the Uinta Mountain trails with his pack horses. He respects and appreciates the natural beauty of Provo and has the experience ande wisdom to protect this beauty. I will certainly vote for Steve Clark

Comment on Issues to Address – Letters to Brent Wilde by Kari McMurtrey

Kari McMurtrey — Fri, 17 Jul 2009 16:07:12 +0000

Mr. Wilde,
My husband & I moved to the area from Seattle one year ago. One of the first places we went to was Rock Canyon for hiking. We saw it from the freeway & found our way over there; its uniqueness drew us to it. Since that first time hiking there last summer, we have returned numerous times. We take out-of-state visitors there to show then our local natural treasure.

I cannot imagine not having this beautiful canyon available to experience and use. It simply would be atrocious to have this amazing piece of geology destroyed by a mine. Should the mine be put in, the probably safety (loose falling rock on trails, trucks on walking paths, etc) and health issues (dust particles/air pollution, contaminated water supply, noise pollution, etc) caused by the mine would be impacting to the local citizens as well as those of us who would still try to use the park.

It is appalling to me that in today’s world that this could even be a possibility that such a wonderful place could be destroyed and turned into a mine.

Sincerely,
Kari McMurtrey

Comment on Saving Rock Canyon on National Trails Day – Saturday, June 6th by Eileen

Eileen — Sat, 04 Jul 2009 15:41:42 +0000

I have followed Mooney’s court case for years. As a Native American person. I want to say that he does not represent the Native American Community of Utah, nor does he have close contact with them, maybe a couple of “hang around the fort indians” but…that does not count. He does not have a voice with the spiritual leaders of our Utah Native American community. He profits off our people. And chooses to test the bounds of Native American religious freedom rights, to the point that the US Government may crack down to legitimate practices. He is all in it for self and profit….our way of life is for sale

Comment on Saving Rock Canyon on National Trails Day – Saturday, June 6th by rockcanyonadvocates

rockcanyonadvocates — Fri, 03 Jul 2009 23:31:14 +0000

Dear “Breadfry”,

We are not affiliated with Mr. Mooney. I would appreciate knowing the source of your information regarding a connection between James Mooney and Preserve Rock Canyon.

Thank you.Rock canyon Advocate

Comment on Issues to Address – Letters to Brent Wilde by Mrs. Alberta Sevy

Mrs. Alberta Sevy — Fri, 29 May 2009 15:33:50 +0000

Dear Mr Wilde, This quote: “Rock Canyon constitutes a natural treasure for our community which could not be reclaimed or restored after mining operation. Its loss would definitely impact the welfare of our citizens” is as succinct as can be said.
I live in “Beautiful British Columbia” and enjoy much natural beauty. Yet, when I come to Provo I head for Rock Canyon! The serenity, the varieties, the healing qualities, even the affect I see the surroundings to have on the people I meet there are profound.
I’ve read the other letters on this page and the key words in each one of them jump out: “sacrifice”, “noise”, “loose rocks” “heavy equipment”, “around the corner from residences”, “truck traffic through residential area” . Each point is so important but the most important of all is: Rock Canyon is a sanctuary that must not be destroyed!!
One writer wrote: “Please represent “the people” on this very dear issue” and “dear” is what the canyon is and has been to thousands of people for so many years.

Please, Mr Wilde, prevent this tragedy.

Thank you

Mrs. Alberta Sevy

Comment on Issues to Address – Letters to Brent Wilde by Whitney Booth

Whitney Booth — Thu, 21 May 2009 22:28:03 +0000

I am not a native of Provo or Utah but being from Western North Carolina I have a deep appreciation for natural beauty and especially Mountains. I am always in awe when I see the mountains in Utah and have enjoyed spending time exploring them. Rock canyon is no exception. It is a national treasure and maybe more importantly a treasure to those who vacate this area. I never see tourist advertisements for Utah proclaiming their exceptionally advanced mining equipment but I see commercials portraying the beautiful rocky landscapes of Utah. It is within these rocky terrains that people who live in and visit Utah enjoy the beauty of the great outdoors! Rock Canyon falls under this category as many people go there to rock climb, bike ride, or merely enjoy the sounds of “ “ rushing waters as they walk. Rock Canyon is a gathering place for friends and families, the basis of our community. One day as I ventured up into Rock Canyon I saw a boy scout troop exploring and learning about the historical canyon. It is possible that many of you reading this have sons or grandsons who also partake in boy scouting activities that take them out into nature to fulfill a merit badge of some sort. Some day if this Canyon is not preserved they may no longer have the opportunity to explore a beautiful place like Rock Canyon, denying them a possible eagle award. Even those who do not venture out into Rock Canyon may be affected by the mining done there with the potential hazard of contaminating Provo city water supply. These examples portray the basic principle that one cannot expect to change one thing without affecting others. Of course this way of thought may also be looked at in a positive manner regarding Rock Canyon. You have the opportunity to preserve something beautiful, continue a legacy, and allow people to continue to enjoy all of the recreational activities available to them in the canyon.
In my own life I have seen the affects of positive action. In deciding to be more health conscious, environmentally friendly and helping lessen the parking burden on Provo I have enjoyed riding my bike all over the city. It was this decisions that led me to find out about critical mass bike riding up to the canyon, which then led me to find out about the opportunity to help be a part of preserving the canyon. This is an opportunity for the community to come together and rekindle ideals that are still important; sacrifice over greed, beauty over destruction, health over idleness and the list could go on. In other words you have the power to make an impact on what is your community. The choice is yours whether or not you want to preserve your own legacy of leadership by preserving this Canyon.

Comment on Forest Service Contacts by carl mccrory

carl mccrory — Thu, 21 May 2009 22:21:28 +0000

hello my name is Carl McCrory and i have been living in Provo for the last 5 years attending BYU. During these years rock canyon has been a constant source of adventure and refuge for me. i am an avid rock climber and have had some of my best climbing experiences right here in rock canyon along with countless other climbers i know. when i heard that this canyon was under threat of being quarried i was shocked that such an idea could possibly be conceived. now i am not familiar with all of the details of what would actually happen to the canyon, but any alteration to the beauty of this area would be devastating to rock climbers, hikers, mountain bikers and nature lovers at large. not to mention the potential threat it poses towards the wildlife. this also poses a potential problem to students of geology. one of my favorite experiences in rock canyon was as a geology student on a field trip to learn of all the different rock formations present in one location. this experience increased my understanding and appreciation for the rock that i climb.

Comment on Rock Canyon “Bowl” Park Meeting by Colleen Tidwell

Colleen Tidwell — Thu, 21 May 2009 15:33:39 +0000

I attended that meeting- it was mostly an information gathering meeting for those who attended to find out what the owner intended to do. We were allowed to ask questions of Mr Park and a representative from Provo city offices after they each gave a short assessment of the situation as they saw it. A geologist also attended and asserted that the rock Mr Davis intends to have mined is common and found all over Utah. Maps were shown of the concerned area

Residents asked if studies had been started on the impact of the trucks, machinery and actual mining on the environment of and near the proposed site. Concerns were raised about ruining a favorite recreation site that the city and many indiviuals have put much care and work into. Safety, noise and particulates in the air were also concerns. I did not hear one supportive comment from any attendee for the mining of the canyon. Mostly people were autraged and astounded that a conditional use permit was even being considered for Rock Canyon.

Comment on Issues to Address – Letters to Brent Wilde by Paige Nuffer

Paige Nuffer — Wed, 20 May 2009 04:47:42 +0000

If the beautiful landscape and sentimental value of the canyon is not an issue to those requesting the quarry, perhaps money would make more sense as an argument.

The neighborhoods in the area should be a top consideration. This mining operation will lower property value (don’t need any more help with that). There will be long-term costs for road repair – close to the canyon, the neighborhoods, and all roads used to haul the heavy rocks. And, damage from truck debris will add up quickly.

There will be a huge noise factor – also lowering property value. Safety and claims for damages and potential injuries will also be costly.

Has anyone contacted the LDS church about voicing a concern about bothersome traffic and noise around the LDS temple? This particular area of Provo is used by many people who worship both inside and outside in many ways.